Skip to content
espresso machine sale

Home › Guides › Espresso machine vs Keurig

Espresso machine vs Keurig: which should you buy?

A Keurig makes a cup of brewed coffee from a pod at the touch of a button. An espresso machine forces hot water through finely ground coffee under pressure. They solve different problems.

By Daniel Russo. Updated .

A stovetop moka pot next to a compact pump espresso machine
The short answer

Buy a Keurig if you want fast, no-fuss cups of regular coffee, tea or cocoa from a pod with almost no cleanup. Buy an espresso machine if you want real espresso and milk drinks like lattes and cappuccinos and are willing to learn, or pay for a bean-to-cup model that does the work. If you want both convenience and espresso, a capsule espresso system or a bean-to-cup machine bridges the gap.

The short answer

If you wantChoose
The quickest cup with the least effortKeurig
A wide range of pod flavors, tea and cocoaKeurig
Real espresso with cremaEspresso machine
Lattes and cappuccinos with real steamed milkEspresso machine
To use fresh beans and control the grindEspresso machine
Convenience with espresso-style drinksA capsule espresso system or a bean-to-cup machine

Head to head

KeurigEspresso machine
Coffee styleBrewed, single-serve cup, usually milderConcentrated espresso, about 25 to 30 ml per shot
IngredientK-Cup pods of pre-ground coffee, tea, cocoa and moreFresh beans ground to order, or pods on capsule models
SkillAlmost noneLow on bean-to-cup machines, high on manual ones
Time per drinkUnder a minuteA few minutes, or one touch on bean-to-cup
Milk drinksModels with a frother, or a separate frotherSteam wand or automatic milk system
CleaningDescale occasionally and rinse the pod holderDaily rinse, weekly cleaning and descaling
VarietyHundreds of pod varietiesAny beans you like
ControlLimited to cup size and strengthGrind, dose, temperature and pressure on many machines

What a Keurig does

Keurig is a single-serve brewing system. You insert a K-Cup pod, which holds ground coffee, tea, cocoa or another drink mix, and the machine brews one cup. The company says its line spans hundreds of varieties from dozens of brands, including coffee, tea, hot chocolate, cider and flavored drinks, which is a large part of its appeal. Brewing is fast, there is nothing to grind or tamp, and cleanup is minimal.

The trade-off is the coffee itself. A K-Cup brews a milder drink than espresso, and the pods hold a smaller amount of coffee than many people would use in other brewers. It is not designed to make espresso, and it cannot make a latte with steamed milk unless you add a separate frother or choose a model with a built-in one.

What an espresso machine does

An espresso machine forces hot water through finely ground coffee under pressure, typically around 9 bar, to make a small, concentrated drink topped with crema. A standard shot is about 25 to 30 ml and takes about 25 to 30 seconds. That concentrated base is the foundation for lattes, cappuccinos, Americanos and flat whites. Some machines also have a steam wand for milk.

There are several kinds, from manual and semi-automatic machines, where you do most of the work, to super-automatic machines that grind, dose, tamp and brew at a button press. See our guides to the best espresso machines for beginners and the best super-automatic machines.

Taste and quality

Espresso has a rich, thick body and a layer of crema, and it is the base for most cafe drinks. A Keurig gives you a lighter cup that behaves more like a small drip coffee. Which you prefer comes down to taste, not an absolute ranking. If you love strong, concentrated coffee or want to taste differences between beans, an espresso machine gives you more to work with. If you like a mild, consistent cup, a Keurig is fine.

Freshness also matters. A pod holds coffee that was ground and sealed earlier, while an espresso machine with a grinder uses fresh beans for each drink. Fresh grounds usually taste better, but you must buy and store beans properly.

Milk drinks

If you want lattes or cappuccinos, an espresso machine with a steam wand or automatic frother is the natural fit. You can steam milk to a silky texture and pour real microfoam. A Keurig can make a coffee-based milk drink only with an added frother, and a few models include one with a shot-style setting for stronger coffee. For technique, see our guides to making a cappuccino and steaming milk, or our milk frother guide.

Effort and cleaning

TaskKeurigEspresso machine
DailyEmpty and refill the tank, discard the podRinse the portafilter, wipe the wand and empty trays
WeeklyWash the removable partsWash trays, tank and parts; backflush if supported
PeriodicDescaleDescale, replace filters and gaskets
LearningMinutesDays to weeks on manual models

Bean-to-cup machines reduce the work, but they still need regular cleaning. See how to clean an espresso machine for a routine.

Cost of ownership

A Keurig typically costs less to buy than an espresso machine, and pods are sold almost everywhere. Over time, the price per cup depends on the pods you buy, and pods often cost more per cup than beans. An espresso machine costs more up front, and you also need a grinder unless your machine has one, though fresh beans are usually cheaper per cup than premium pods. Prices change often and vary by retailer, so compare current listings.

Waste and the environment

K-Cup pods are plastic, and their waste is a common complaint. Reusable filter cups are available, and they let you use ground coffee in a Keurig. Espresso machines produce used grounds that can be composted. Capsule espresso systems use aluminum or plastic capsules, and some makers run recycling programs. If this matters to you, choose a system with a recycling program or a machine that uses beans.

The middle ground

If you want the speed of a pod machine and something closer to espresso, you have options.

If you only want a cup of coffee and not espresso, a drip brewer may be all you need. See espresso machine vs coffee maker.

Two kinds of capsule espresso: Original and Vertuo

If you are leaning toward capsules, know that Nespresso sells two systems. The Original line uses small capsules and brews espresso-style shots using pressure, and you can choose a single shot or a longer lungo. The newer Vertuo line, introduced in 2014, uses larger capsules with a barcode on the rim that tells the machine how much water, at what temperature, and how fast to spin the capsule during brewing, so it can make both espresso-style shots and full cups of coffee. Keurig only takes K-Cup pods, while Nespresso capsules are proprietary and made for Nespresso machines. Our Nespresso guide compares the machines.

Questions to ask yourself

QuestionIf yesIf no
Do I want real espresso or milk drinks?Espresso machineKeurig is enough
Am I willing to learn a routine?Semi-automatic or manual machinePod or bean-to-cup machine
Do I need tea and cocoa from the same machine?KeurigAny
Do I want to use fresh beans?Espresso machine with a grinderPods
Is counter space tight?Compact machine or KeurigAny
Will many people use it?Keurig or bean-to-cupAny

Office and shared kitchens

Keurig machines began in offices, and they are still a common choice there because a pod brews quickly, needs no training and lets each person pick a different drink. A bean-to-cup machine is also a good office choice, but it needs someone to clean the drip tray, bin and milk system. See our office espresso machine guide for more.

Common myths

  • "A pod machine makes espresso." Only capsule espresso systems and machines built for it do, and a Keurig makes a brewed cup.
  • "Espresso machines are always hard." Bean-to-cup machines make a drink at the touch of a button.
  • "Pods are always cheaper." Pod prices vary widely, and fresh beans are often cheaper per cup.
  • "Espresso is stronger in caffeine per cup." A shot is small. A full cup of brewed coffee can contain more caffeine in total, so compare serving sizes.

Who should buy which

If youBuy
Drink one or two mild coffees a day and want no hassleKeurig
Share a machine with people who like tea and cocoaKeurig
Love lattes and cappuccinosEspresso machine, ideally with a steam wand or milk system
Want to learn the craftSemi-automatic or manual espresso machine
Want espresso with one buttonSuper-automatic or capsule espresso system
Want drip coffee and espresso in one bodyCombination machine

Questions people ask

Is a Keurig an espresso machine?

No. A Keurig brews a single cup of coffee from a pod. Real espresso is made by forcing hot water through finely ground coffee at about 9 bar of pressure.

Can a Keurig make espresso?

Some models have a stronger or shot-style setting, but the result is a concentrated coffee, not true espresso with crema from a pressurized machine.

Which is better, a Keurig or an espresso machine?

Neither is better in every way. A Keurig is faster and easier, and an espresso machine makes real espresso and milk drinks.

Is an espresso machine harder to use than a Keurig?

Manual machines are, and they take practice. Bean-to-cup machines can be nearly as easy as a Keurig.

Which is cheaper to run?

It depends on the pods and beans you buy. Pods often cost more per cup than beans, but an espresso machine costs more to buy.

Can I make lattes with a Keurig?

Only with a separate frother or a model with a built-in frother. The coffee will be milder than espresso.

Are K-Cups recyclable?

Policies vary by place and product. Reusable filter cups reduce waste.

What is between a Keurig and an espresso machine?

Capsule espresso systems and super-automatic bean-to-cup machines, which give you espresso-style drinks with little effort.

Can I use my own coffee in a Keurig?

Yes, with a reusable filter cup. It lets you fill the pod holder with ground coffee, though the result will still be a brewed cup rather than espresso.

Do I need a grinder for an espresso machine?

Unless your machine has a built-in grinder or uses pods, yes. A grinder with fine adjustment makes a big difference.

Which is better for lattes, a Keurig or a Nespresso?

A Nespresso Vertuo or Original machine with a milk frother gets closer to a latte than a Keurig, because the coffee is more concentrated. For a real latte with steamed milk, use an espresso machine.

Which lasts longer, a Keurig or an espresso machine?

Lifespan depends on the model, water hardness and how well you descale. Regular cleaning and descaling extend the life of either machine.

Is an espresso machine worth it if I only drink one cup a day?

It can be. A compact bean-to-cup or capsule machine makes one drink quickly, while a manual machine suits people who enjoy the routine.

Can I own both a Keurig and an espresso machine?

Yes, and some households do. A pod brewer handles quick cups and guests who want tea, while an espresso machine handles milk drinks on weekends. Consider counter space and whether you will use both.

How long do pods stay fresh?

Sealed pods keep well until their date, but coffee tastes best soon after roasting. Store them in a cool, dry place, and use beans within a few weeks of roasting for the best flavor.

Sources

  1. Keurig (Wikipedia)
  2. Espresso (Wikipedia)
  3. Single-serve coffee container (Wikipedia)

Read next